Xinhua
31 Jul 2025, 22:15 GMT+10
GAZA, July 31 (Xinhua) -- U.S. President Donald Trump recently admitted that Gaza is experiencing "real starvation," and announced plans to set up new food distribution centers overseen by Israel in the territory.
Referring to the past chaos and killings caused by the U.S. and Israel-supported aid distribution mechanism in Gaza, Palestinian analysts and residents argued that Trump's recent change in tone is simply a political maneuver aimed at placating public opinion, and is unlikely to lead to a real change in U.S. policy regarding the ongoing crisis in Gaza.
"The U.S. acknowledgment of starvation carries legal and moral weight, but remains symbolic unless translated into meaningful policy change," Hussam al-Dajani, a Gaza-based political analyst, told Xinhua.
"When the most powerful country in the world acknowledges starvation somewhere, this carries obligations. But instead of leading to protective action, it has resulted in reinforcing the mechanisms of suffering by assigning aid oversight to Israel," he said.
"This approach does not serve the interests of the civilian population but perpetuates their vulnerability," he added.
Al-Dajani explained that the aid model now being proposed by the United States risks turning humanitarian assistance into a political tool, rather than a means of relief.
"We are seeing an aid system designed not to save lives, but to manage and control populations under siege," he said.
Esmat Mansour, a Ramallah-based political analyst, shared similar concerns. He described the U.S. initiative as legitimizing an "aid regime" that is closely tied to military structures and security agendas.
"Israel does not deliver aid. It manages access to aid in ways that serve its broader strategic goals," Mansour told Xinhua.
"The United States has chosen to reinforce that framework instead of proposing an independent humanitarian mechanism, further blurring the line between relief and control," he said.
According to Mansour, Gaza's humanitarian crisis is not only the result of war, but also of a carefully engineered system of deprivation.
"The goal appears to be to keep the population in a constant state of need and exhaustion," he said. "The starvation is being used as a soft pressure mechanism, and the United States is complicit by supporting the very structures that produce it."
Hani al-Masri, a Ramallah-based analyst, told Xinhua, "The U.S. announcement was likely a response to mounting international pressure and global media coverage, rather than a substantive policy pivot."
"This acknowledgment does not come from a place of humanitarian concern, but rather from the need to manage reputational damage," al-Masri said.
He warned that empowering Israel to distribute aid as its military operations continue could pave the way for "a reinforced occupation model."
"Providing food under fire, with no ceasefire in place, undermines any credibility the United States claims in humanitarian leadership," al-Masri said.
Since March 2, a renewed Israeli blockade has closed all Gaza crossings, halting the delivery of food, fuel, and medicine into the enclave. Ceasefire talks have stalled, with some critics pointing to unwavering U.S. support for Israel as a key roadblock.
Claiming to help alleviate the deteriorating humanitarian situation for Palestinians in Gaza, the U.S.-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation established two food distribution centers in late May. Subsequently, it opened two additional centers in central and northern Gaza.
However, residents said these food distribution centers haven't truly improved their lives or stopped them from going hungry.
Gaza-based health authorities said Wednesday that a total of 154 people, including 89 children, have died from starvation and malnutrition.
Khaled al-Za'noun, a Palestinian man from al-Zeitoun neighborhood in Gaza City, told Xinhua that, "Every time we hear that an American food center has opened ... we rush there, wait for hours, and usually return with nothing."
"Four weeks ago, my cousin was shot trying to grab a bag of flour. We couldn't save him. We ran for our lives," he said, dismissing the centers as chaotic and unsafe.
In central Gaza's Maghazi refugee camp, 40-year-old widow Om Sami al-Sheikh waited for six hours outside a food distribution center. "I came back with nothing."
Her 11-month-old baby, visibly malnourished, lay beside her as she spoke.
"The United States says it cares, but it funds this suffering and sends food through centers that humiliate us," she lamented. "If they really wanted to help, we wouldn't be starving like this. They are not just bystanders; they're part of what's killing us."
Get a daily dose of Calgary Monitor news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Calgary Monitor.
More InformationGAZA, July 31 (Xinhua) -- U.S. President Donald Trump recently admitted that Gaza is experiencing real starvation, and announced plans...
(Photo credit: REUTERS/Tingshu Wang) Canada's Summer McIntosh dominated the 200-meter butterfly on Thursday to claim her third gold...
The billionaires foundation was allegedly involved in the 2016 smear campaign and in instigating the FBI probe into the collusion claim...
Washington DC [US], July 31 (ANI): US President Donald Trump has offered a straightforward solution to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza,...
Frankfurt [Germany] July 31 (ANI): The Chairman of the Jeay Sindh Muttahida Mahaz (JSMM), Shafi Burfat, has criticised the United States...
(250731) -- SINGAPORE, July 31, 2025 (Xinhua) -- Jack alexy of the United States celebrates after the men's 100m freestyle final of...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: As cannabis-infused drinks grow in popularity and take over retail shelf space once dominated by beer and...
(Photo credit: REUTERS/Tingshu Wang) Canada's Summer McIntosh dominated the 200-meter butterfly on Thursday to claim her third gold...
(Photo credit: Mitch Stringer-Imagn Images) The Houston Astros got their third baseman, acquiring Ramon Urias and cash considerations...
(Photo credit: Lisa Scalfaro / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images) The Toronto Blue Jays acquired former American League Cy Young...
(250731) -- SINGAPORE, July 31, 2025 (Xinhua) -- Summer McIntosh of Canada celebrates after the women's 200m butterfly final of swimming...
Washington DC [US], July 31 (ANI): The 'Cinderella' actress Lily James is set to star opposite actor Chris Hemsworth for a new submarine...
